I agree with you completely, Shane, but it seems to be a minority opinion on the site. I have leveled some criticism but refrained from most of it. Instead of suggesting improvements, I ask questions. Many of those questions are sincere, that is, I really want to know something more about what the author thinks or means. But some of them are roundabout ways of pointing to something that needs clarification, or that I disagree with.

So feel free to point out ways that I can make my writing better!